Compare Specs and Costs · Australia
HP vs Brother Printer Lease in Australia
Printers updated one at a time can bring unplanned work for a small IT team, so central management is worth comparing.
On a Kyocera, HP, Toshiba or Brother lease from us, toner, parts, service and call outs sit inside one set monthly payment, so paper is the only thing you buy.
Both brands lease as A4 business multifunction devices.
HP leads with the Color LaserJet Enterprise platform, deep device security and central fleet management.
The Brother MFC-L range is built for a compact desktop footprint and super high yield toner.
The right starting point depends on your fleet tooling, desk space and device class.
Skip to the verdict
Before you enquire
What contract lengths can I choose from?
You choose the term at the start, anywhere from 36 to 60 months.
There is no day, week or month by month arrangement.
What happens at the end of the lease?
At the end you either upgrade, stay on the equipment already in place, or hand it back.
We contact you before the date so it is never missed, and the terms of whichever path you pick are confirmed in writing.
What if we outgrow the machine?
You can move up a device class or swap models during the term, once the change is quoted and agreed.
New equipment arrives within 10 business days of a confirmed order, installation included.
Is my business too small to lease?
There is no minimum size.
The useful test is volume.
Above about 500 pages a month, one monthly set plan is normally simpler.
The plan covers maintenance, genuine toner and remote diagnostics, instead of buying cartridges and paying for callouts.
Can you quote if our current lease has not finished?
Yes, and it is a common position to be in.
We quote now and set the installation against your current lease end date, so there is no overlap and no outage.
Check your existing notice window early, because those dates are easy to miss.
Enquired on Monday and had a printer installed by Friday. Fast, easy, and exactly what we needed.
Get a HP or Brother lease quote
Last updated: October 2026
Is HP or Brother better for a printer lease in Australia?
Neither brand wins for every office: HP suits IT teams standardising security and fleet management on HP, while Brother suits compact A4 only offices wanting long gaps between toner changes.
HP leads with A4 Color LaserJet Enterprise multifunction devices (25 to 60+ pages per minute), plus A3 LaserJet Enterprise MFP models.
HP adds Wolf Security firmware protection and Web Jetadmin fleet management.
On the Brother side, the MFC-L range is A4 only, running 31 to 50 pages per minute from a compact footprint with super high yield toner cartridges.
Both brands are leased by LeasemyPrinter from $160 a month (plus GST) on a 36 to 60 month term, with maintenance, genuine consumables and remote diagnostics covered for the contract term.
Some businesses call it printer hire, some call it copier rental. It is the same 36 to 60 month agreement with toner, parts, service labour and call outs included, never day or week hire.
Ready to lease rather than compare? See our HP printer lease and Brother printer lease options.
Talk to a HP and Brother leasing specialist
We have leased printers to Australian businesses since 2010, with 153 Google reviews.
1300 873 460HP vs Brother: side by side
Class of device
- HP
- A4 colour MFP (Color LaserJet Enterprise), plus A3 LaserJet Enterprise MFP models
- Brother
- A4 mono and A4 colour MFP (MFC-L range)
Largest sheet size
- HP
- A3 (LaserJet Enterprise MFP models)
- Brother
- A4
Speed band
- HP
- 25 to 60+ ppm common configurations
- Brother
- 31 to 50 ppm across the MFC-L range
Consumable design
- HP
- Genuine HP toner included in the lease
- Brother
- Super high yield toner options across the MFC-L range
Device security
- HP
- HP Sure Start, runtime intrusion detection and secure print release (HP Wolf Security)
- Brother
- Secure-print release and NFC card authentication on advanced models (e.g. MFC-L8900CDW)
Scan workflow
- HP
- Scan to folder, email and SharePoint via HP JetAdvantage
- Brother
- Scan to folder, email and the Brother iPrint&Scan app
Fleet management
- HP
- HP Web Jetadmin and JetAdvantage for multi-device estates
- Brother
- Suited to single-site and branch deployments
Mobile / cloud print
- HP
- AirPrint, Mopria, HP Smart
- Brother
- AirPrint, NFC tap to print, WiFi Direct, Brother iPrint&Scan
Finishing
- HP
- Stapler and hole punch on enterprise A3 and high-end A4 models
- Brother
- Automatic duplex and multi tray paper handling; no booklet finishing
Footprint
- HP
- Desktop and floor standing enterprise options
- Brother
- Compact desktop footprint
Typical lease entry
- HP
- From $160 a month (plus GST) on a 36 to 60 month term
- Brother
- From $160 a month (plus GST) on a 36 to 60 month term
| Factor | HP | Brother |
|---|---|---|
| Class of device | A4 colour MFP (Color LaserJet Enterprise), plus A3 LaserJet Enterprise MFP models | A4 mono and A4 colour MFP (MFC-L range) |
| Largest sheet size | A3 (LaserJet Enterprise MFP models) | A4 |
| Speed band | 25 to 60+ ppm common configurations | 31 to 50 ppm across the MFC-L range |
| Consumable design | Genuine HP toner included in the lease | Super high yield toner options across the MFC-L range |
| Device security | HP Sure Start, runtime intrusion detection and secure print release (HP Wolf Security) | Secure-print release and NFC card authentication on advanced models (e.g. MFC-L8900CDW) |
| Scan workflow | Scan to folder, email and SharePoint via HP JetAdvantage | Scan to folder, email and the Brother iPrint&Scan app |
| Fleet management | HP Web Jetadmin and JetAdvantage for multi-device estates | Suited to single-site and branch deployments |
| Mobile / cloud print | AirPrint, Mopria, HP Smart | AirPrint, NFC tap to print, WiFi Direct, Brother iPrint&Scan |
| Finishing | Stapler and hole punch on enterprise A3 and high-end A4 models | Automatic duplex and multi tray paper handling; no booklet finishing |
| Footprint | Desktop and floor standing enterprise options | Compact desktop footprint |
| Typical lease entry | From $160 a month (plus GST) on a 36 to 60 month term | From $160 a month (plus GST) on a 36 to 60 month term |
How we compare: this table is based on published manufacturer specifications and publicly available product documentation, reviewed October 2026, not independent lab testing.
Brand and product names on this page are trade marks of their respective owners. LeasemyPrinter is an independent printer leasing business.
We are not an authorised dealer for, affiliated with, or endorsed by any brand we do not lease.
How HP and Brother weigh up
Each side's device class, weighed on the same points, resolving to the brands we lease.
HP strengths
- Deep device security stack (HP Sure Start, runtime intrusion detection) suited to security conscious IT teams.
- HP Web Jetadmin fleet management for large, multi site A4 estates.
- A natural fit for organisations already standardised on HP across their IT environment.
Brother strengths
- Long gaps between toner changes with super high yield options.
- Compact desktop footprint suited to small offices and branch sites.
- Simple setup and intuitive touchscreen operation.
When HP is the starting point
- IT teams standardising device security and fleet management on HP across the organisation.
- Multi site estates that manage devices centrally with HP Web Jetadmin.
- Offices that occasionally need A3 via the LaserJet Enterprise MFP models.
When Brother is the starting point
- Small offices and branch sites whose output is A4 only and where desk space is tight.
- Businesses wanting long gaps between toner changes on moderate monthly volumes.
- Teams wanting a simple, compact device with minimal setup.
Still weighing HP against Brother for your office?
Answer 5 quick questions about your print volume, colour use and lease length.
The free quiz takes about 2 minutes and matches you to one Kyocera printer with an estimated monthly cost.
Other brands we lease are quoted on request. No obligation.
How to choose between HP and Brother
- Estimate your monthly print volume and your colour versus mono split, because that sizes the device class before any brand decision.
- Decide whether you need A3. The Brother MFC-L business range is A4, while HP adds A3 LaserJet Enterprise MFP models. Confirm the largest sheet size your workflow uses.
- Weigh footprint against fleet tooling. Brother is the compact A4 option with super high yield toner; HP adds Web Jetadmin and the HP Wolf Security stack.
- Next business day onsite response for confirmed service requests applies Australia wide, and that matters more than headline specs once the device is installed.
- Request a side by side HP and Brother MFC-L lease quote for your volume and term, and compare the total monthly cost with maintenance and consumables included.
Before you sign
Seven things to check on the quote, whichever of HP and Brother you pick
Brand comparisons tend to stop at speed and price.
The complaints that show up a year later are usually about none of that.
The operating details below decide whether a device suits your office, and each one comes with the exact question to ask about the model you are quoted.
We have not bench tested these machines, so the figures below are the ones to request rather than ones we assert.
1. Warm up and first page out time
A device that sleeps deeply saves power and then makes everyone wait. In an office of short, frequent jobs this is felt more than the headline speed.
Ask: Ask for first page out time from sleep, not just pages per minute, on the exact model quoted.
2. Scan resolution and duplex scanning
If paper enters your document system through this machine, scan quality and whether it captures both sides in one pass matter more than print speed.
Ask: Ask for the optical scan resolution and whether the feeder is single pass duplex.
3. Recommended monthly volume, not maximum duty cycle
Maximum duty cycle is a survival figure. The recommended monthly volume is the one the device is built to run at without accelerating wear.
Ask: Ask for the recommended monthly volume and compare it to your actual monthly pages.
4. Toner yield and what a full set costs
Yield varies widely between models at similar prices. On an all inclusive agreement this is our cost rather than yours, but it tells you how the device was specified.
Ask: Ask for the rated yield per cartridge at 5 per cent coverage for the model quoted.
5. Driver and firmware support on your systems
The most common post install complaint in IT forums is not hardware. It is a driver that fights a particular operating system, print server or scan to folder setup.
Ask: Name your operating systems and whether you use a print server, before you sign, not after.
6. Finishing fitted at install
Stapling, hole punch and extra trays are fitted to the device. Adding them later is not a simple upgrade on a three to five year agreement.
Ask: Describe the documents you actually produce so the finisher is specified once, correctly.
7. Who attends, and how fast
Two identical machines differ entirely depending on whether a technician is local or dispatched from a capital city.
Ask: Ask where the nearest technician is based and what the onsite response commitment is in writing.
Ready to lease HP or Brother? Get your quote
Before you enquire
What contract lengths can I choose from?
You choose the term at the start, anywhere from 36 to 60 months.
There is no day, week or month by month arrangement.
What happens at the end of the lease?
At the end you either upgrade, stay on the equipment already in place, or hand it back.
We contact you before the date so it is never missed, and the terms of whichever path you pick are confirmed in writing.
What if we outgrow the machine?
You can move up a device class or swap models during the term, once the change is quoted and agreed.
New equipment arrives within 10 business days of a confirmed order, installation included.
Is my business too small to lease?
There is no minimum size.
The useful test is volume.
Above about 500 pages a month, one monthly set plan is normally simpler.
The plan covers maintenance, genuine toner and remote diagnostics, instead of buying cartridges and paying for callouts.
Can you quote if our current lease has not finished?
Yes, and it is a common position to be in.
We quote now and set the installation against your current lease end date, so there is no overlap and no outage.
Check your existing notice window early, because those dates are easy to miss.
Frequently asked questions
Is HP or Brother better for office printer leasing in Australia?
Neither is universally "better".
They optimise for different offices.
HP leads with the Color LaserJet Enterprise platform, a deep device security stack and central fleet management, while the Brother MFC-L range is built for a compact footprint and super high yield toner.
A multi site organisation managing devices centrally usually matches the HP profile.
A small or branch office printing A4 in a tight space usually matches Brother.
We lease both and can put a like for like quote in front of you for either brand.
Does the lease pricing differ between HP and Brother?
Leases on HP and Brother start from $160 a month (plus GST) on a 36 to 60 month term, covering maintenance, genuine consumables and remote diagnostics.
Where your figure lands depends on device class, speed, options and how much you print each month.
Is HP or Brother cheaper for me to run?
On a LeasemyPrinter lease, toner, parts and service labour are built into the monthly figure for both brands, so neither bills them separately.
The monthly figure itself depends on the device class.
What HP adds is security and fleet tooling for larger estates.
Entry tier leases on either start from $160 a month (plus GST) on a 36 to 60 month term, with maintenance and genuine consumables covered.
There is no page allowance and no per page rate on either brand, so a busy month leaves the invoice unchanged.
Can I run a mixed HP and Brother fleet?
Yes.
The lease can cover both brands on a single agreement with consolidated billing.
For example, compact Brother A4 devices at branch desks and HP enterprise devices at head office.
The trade off is two toner families and two management toolsets, which we factor into the service plan.
Not ready for a quote yet?
Book a time for us to call you, or read the buyer's guide first.
